All Ask Sylvia answers

Ask Sylvia · Financing

How do I compare loan estimates from different lenders?

Short Answer

The Loan Estimate is a standardized three-page form every lender must give you within three business days of your application. Because the format is the same for every lender, you can compare offers section by section: loan terms, projected payments, closing costs, and the page-3 comparisons.

Published Updated

The Loan Estimate is a standardized three-page form that every lender must give you within three business days of your application. Because the format is identical for every lender, the same items appear in the same place on every offer, which is what makes line-by-line comparison possible. The CFPB's Loan Estimate explainer walks through the form page by page, and this answer follows the same structure: loan terms, projected payments, closing cost details, and the page-3 comparisons.

Before you compare: make the offers match

Set up a fair comparison from the start. Each estimate should be for the same loan amount, the same loan term, and the same loan type (conventional, FHA, or VA), and the rates should be quoted or locked the same way and around the same time. Comparing offers built on different assumptions tells you more about the assumptions than about the lenders.

Page 1: loan terms and projected payments

Page 1 opens with the loan terms: the loan amount, the interest rate, the monthly principal and interest payment, whether the rate can increase after closing, whether there is a prepayment penalty, and whether the loan has a balloon payment. Below that, the projected payments section adds the costs the lender will collect each month: estimated property taxes, homeowners insurance, and homeowners association dues where they exist, plus the total monthly payment.

When you compare loan terms across estimates, confirm you are comparing the same loan amount and term, then check whether the rate is locked and for how long. A rate that can change before closing changes the payment on the page.

Pages 1 and 2: closing cost details

The closing cost details start on page 1 and continue onto page 2. The loan costs section lists the origination charges the lender controls, the services you can shop for (such as the appraisal and the title search), and the services you cannot shop for because the lender requires specific providers. The other costs section covers property taxes, insurance, and the prepaid items you will pay at closing, plus the initial escrow deposit. Cash to close appears on both pages and shows what you will actually need to bring to the table.

The numbers to read closely are the origination charges, which vary from lender to lender, and the estimates for taxes and insurance, which should be similar no matter who your lender is. Ask the lender to explain anything that does not match what you were quoted.

Page 3: the comparison

Page 3 puts the offer in context. It shows the annual percentage rate (APR), which folds the interest rate and many loan costs into one annualized number, the total interest percentage, and the cost of the loan over the first five years. It also lists cash to close and the amount held in escrow, and it repeats the borrower and lender details. Where a lender is eligible, the final section compares up to three offers side by side.

A lower interest rate is not automatically the cheaper loan if the fees are higher, so compare the whole picture: the loan terms, the projected payments, the closing cost details, and the page-3 totals. This page sticks to how to compare the form; it does not quote rates or example figures.

Comparing estimates across lenders

Lay the estimates side by side and work top to bottom: confirm the loan terms match, compare the projected payments, compare the closing cost details, then compare the page-3 totals. If one offer looks better on page 1 but worse on page 2, the full picture decides. Once you can see the offers on equal footing, the choice between lenders comes down to service, responsiveness, and fit.

Deciding which lenders to apply to in the first place is a separate decision. See What should I compare when choosing a mortgage lender for the questions to ask, local experience, the pre-approval process, and timelines.

FAQ

Q: When do I get a Loan Estimate?

A: Within three business days of submitting a complete application to a lender.

Q: Can I shop with more than one lender?

A: Yes. Getting several Loan Estimates is a normal part of shopping, and comparing them is exactly what the standardized form is for.

Q: Does the Loan Estimate lock my rate?

A: No. The form can note whether the rate is locked and for how long; locking is a separate decision.

Q: What if the estimates I receive are not comparable?

A: Ask each lender to reissue the estimate using the same loan amount, term, and loan type, so you are comparing the same deal.

Answered by

Sylvia Dorrance

Sylvia Dorrance, REALTOR®, licensed real estate salesperson with eXp Realty, LLC.

Idaho License #9671048

More about Sylvia

Your next step

Have a question of your own?

Bring your situation and I will give you a clear, personal answer. Book a call or send a message, and we will talk through your options.

Connect with Sylvia