All Ask Sylvia answers

Ask Sylvia · Selling

What's the difference between a CMA and an appraisal?

Short Answer

A CMA is an agent's pricing estimate based on comparable sales; an appraisal is a licensed appraiser's formal opinion of value ordered by a lender. Both use comps, but they answer different questions for different audiences.

Published Updated

A comparative market analysis (CMA) compares your home to recently sold, pending, and active listings to estimate a competitive list price. It's a marketing and pricing tool, prepared by an agent, and it's the basis for the listing price. An appraisal is prepared by a state-licensed appraiser using a standardized process, and the lender uses it to decide how much it will finance. The appraiser's value is an independent opinion, not a negotiation.

The practical difference: a CMA is about what the market will bear for a listing; an appraisal is about what the lender will lend against. They usually land near each other, but they can differ, and a low appraisal doesn't always mean a low CMA, or vice versa. This page covers the difference briefly; the two answers linked below go deeper.

FAQ

Q: Does the CMA set the appraisal value?

A: No. The appraiser does their own analysis and is not required to follow the list price.

Q: Who orders each one?

A: The agent prepares a CMA before listing; the lender orders an appraisal as part of the loan process.

Q: What happens if the appraisal comes in low?

A: See the linked appraisal answer for the options.

Sources

General guidance based on standard real estate practice. For current Ada County figures, see the market page: What's happening in the Boise area housing market right now? Sources checked October 22, 2026.

Answered by

Sylvia Dorrance

Sylvia Dorrance, REALTOR®, licensed real estate salesperson with eXp Realty, LLC.

Idaho License #9671048

More about Sylvia

Your next step

Have a question of your own?

Bring your situation and I will give you a clear, personal answer. Book a call or send a message, and we will talk through your options.

Connect with Sylvia